MINNEAPOLIS, Minn. – The plaintiff, represented by Adam M. Evans from The Carlson Law Firm and co-counsel Rhett McSweeney, secured a favorable ruling after the Hennepin County District Court denied substantial portions of Medtronic's motion to dismiss, allowing the core claims in the spinal cord stimulator lawsuit to move forward.
The lawsuit alleges that the patient suffered serious injuries related to a Medtronic spinal cord stimulation system after undergoing an MRI procedure in February 2024. According to the complaint, the plaintiff placed the device into MRI Mode as instructed before the scan. During the MRI, he allegedly experienced severe pain, and the device's leads reportedly shifted, causing further injury and ultimately requiring removal of the system.
Court Allows Key Claims Against Medtronic to Proceed
In a detailed order issued by Judge Michael K. Browne, the court rejected much of Medtronic's effort to end the case at the pleading stage. The ruling permits several of the lawsuit's principal causes of action to proceed, including claims for manufacturing defects, failure to warn, breach of express warranty, breach of implied warranty, statutory negligence, and violations of the Ohio Consumer Protection Act.
Court Rejects Medtronic’s Federal Preemption Argument
Significantly, the court also rejected Medtronic's broad argument that federal law preempted the majority of consumer’s claims. Instead, the court concluded that several claims may move forward because Medtronic failed to demonstrate, at this stage of the proceedings, that they are barred under federal law.
“Preemption is a significant hurdle in defective device litigation,” said Timothy Roers, partner at The Carlson Law Firm. “So this result is a major victory for consumers.
Carlson Attorneys Respond to the Ruling
Elijah Biedinger, an attorney and member of the Leadership Development Committee, described the ruling as a major milestone for the plaintiffs.
“We are the first firm to win a MTD argument against Medtronic,” said Biedinger. “Previously, no claims have made it past this stage. On a 10-claim complaint, we only lost two completely and 2-3 partially.”
About The Carlson Law Firm
The Carlson Law Firm is a nationally recognized personal injury law firm dedicated to delivering compassionate, client-focused legal representation. Known for achieving record-breaking results, we’ve recovered billions by handling cases involving auto and trucking accidents, workplace injuries, defective products, dangerous drugs, nursing home neglect, birth injuries, wrongful death, family law, criminal defense and more. Our attorneys are committed to securing justice and meaningful recovery for individuals and families impacted by negligence and injustice.
Media Contact:
Kazia Conway
kazia@carlsonattorneys.com



